When Your Own Lawyer Lets You Down: A Florida Business Owner’s Guide to Legal Malpractice Claims

You hired a lawyer to protect your company. Then a deadline slipped, a contract turned out to have a costly gap, or a lawsuit fell apart for reasons nobody explained. Was that simply a bad outcome, or was it something more? The difference matters, and it is where most business owners get stuck.
Losing a Case Is Not the Same as Malpractice
Lawyers are not guarantors of results. Plenty of well-handled cases are lost. A legal malpractice claim generally asks two things. Did the lawyer fall short of the care a reasonably careful lawyer would have provided? And did that failure actually cause you a financial loss? The second question trips up many business owners. It is not enough to show a mistake. You have to show you would likely have been better off without it.
Mistakes that commonly lead to these claims include:
- Missing a filing deadline or a limitations period
- Skipping basic research or fact investigation before giving advice
- Drafting an operating agreement, lease, or contract with a gap that costs real money
- Overlooking a conflict of interest
- Failing to pass along a settlement offer or explain a major risk
The Clock Is Already Running
Timing is where good claims go to die. Under section 95.11(5)(b) of the Florida Statutes, an action for professional malpractice, other than medical malpractice, must be brought within two years, whether it is founded on contract or tort. The period runs from the time the cause of action is discovered or should have been discovered with due diligence. That two-year period applies to persons in privity with the professional, which usually means the lawyer’s own client; claims by others may follow different rules.
Notice the phrase “should have been discovered.” A court may decide you ought to have caught the problem sooner than you did. Pinpointing exactly when a claim begins can also get complicated, especially if the original case is still on appeal or has not fully ended. So waiting to see how things shake out can be a costly gamble.
Start Building Your Paper Trail
Gather the engagement letter, invoices, emails, filings, and any drafts of the documents in question. Then write out a timeline of what you asked for, what you were told, and what happened next. Just as important, collect anything that shows what the mistake cost you, such as lost revenue, a failed sale, or a judgment you should never have faced.
Not sure whether what happened to you counts? That is exactly the kind of question we answer. At Pike & Lustig, our West Palm Beach legal malpractice attorneys will look at the facts with you, explain where you stand, and talk through your options. Send us a message through our website and we will take it from there.
Source:
flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/95.11
